힐러리 email 사건정리

민주당의 강력한 대선후보는 힐러리 클린턴이다고 보고 있습니다. 상원하원이 공화당에 넘어간 이상 미국의 유권자들은 민주당에 더 호감을 가질 확률이 높고, 여자라는 점, first lady부터 secretary of state까지, 또한 아내로서 어머니로서 모든것을 다 잘해냈다는 평가가 많을것 같습니다. 본인은 지금까지 좀 빼고 있지만 스스로는 더욱 그렇게 생각할것으로 봅니다. 이런 유력 대선후보를 흔들어놓지 않고선 대선에 이길수가 없겠지요.

당연히 잘못은 했으나, 이런것을 지금에야 들쳐낸것을 보면 정말 정보기관의 정보력은 정말 상상이상인것 같습니다. 2009년에 많은 정치인이 개인 email과 공무 email을 같이 썫어 사용했을것으로 예상됩니다. 그런점을 잘 알고 뒤를 파보면 먼지찾기는 쉽겠지요.

1. blackberry폰에 나라 메일을 자기 서버로 FW해서 자기 email과 같이 관리한점
2. 기밀정보도 보호되지 않은 네트웍에서 access했을 가능성
3. 모르게 해킹당해 기밀이 유출됐을 가능성이 있는점
4. 자기 도메인에 MS Exchange서버가 돌고 있었다면 IT관련 담당자나 외주업체가 있었을텐데 아무도 이렇게 쓰면 나중에 문제될수 있다고 하지 않았다면 이상하네요.
5. 블렉베리가 좋긴좋았구나
6. 한국 대선 후보자중 유력한 후보라면 정말 모든면에서 원칙을 잘 지켜야할듯. 문제인 대표와 박원순 시장은 더욱 명심해야할듯.

Source : WSJ.com

--------------

Mrs. Clinton told reporters her staff erred on the side of disclosure when determining which of her emails were personal and which government business.

Hillary Clinton left the State Department more than two years ago, yet the dispute over her private email account threatens to rage for the next 21 months of the 2016 presidential campaign. On Tuesday, Mrs. Clinton and her office gave the most detailed accounting to date of how and why she used a private account instead of one operated by the federal government.

Below is a timeline of the key points and dates in Mrs. Clinton’s email use.

Jan. 13, 2009: Mrs. Clinton registers the Internet domain clintonemail.com, operated from a private server based in New York.

Jan. 21, 2009: Mrs. Clinton is sworn in as secretary of state.

More In Hillary Clinton

• O'Malley Nods at Clinton's Travails: Frontrunners Not 'Inevitable'
• Poll Shows Younger Americans Tuning Out Clinton Story
• What You Need to Know About Hillary Clinton's Email Account
• Internal Report Finds Shortcomings in State Department Email Retention
• Official: Clinton Couldn't Have Used Two Email Accounts on a Work Phone

March 18, 2009: Mrs. Clinton stops using an email address she used as a senator and begins corresponding using an account on her private server, according to her office. Messages from the account she used as a senator are lost and could not be retrieved, her office said. It isn’t clear what sort of account this was.

Dec. 22, 2010: The National Archives and Records Administration issues guidance to federal agency heads stating that all emails, including attachments, relating to government business are considered records to be preserved under the Federal Records Act.

Feb. 1, 2013: Mrs. Clinton’s tenure as secretary of state ends.

March 3, 2013: Gawker publishes Mrs. Clinton’s email address, hdr22@clintonemail.com, after it is revealed by a hacker who compromised the email account of Sidney Blumenthal, a former aide to President Bill Clinton. Mrs. Clinton changed her address in March 2013, though to what she did not say.

Sept. 15, 2014: The National Archives issued new guidance on personal emails, stating that government officials should not use personal email accounts for official business.

Oct. 28, 2014: The State Department requests the work-related emails of former secretaries, including Mrs. Clinton.

November 2014: The House Select Committee investigating Benghazi requests Mrs. Clinton’s emails about the September 2012 incident at Benghazi, Libya, that killed U.S. ambassador Christopher Stevens and three other Americans. About 300 of Mrs. Clinton’s emails from her private account were delivered to the committee, her office said.

The State Department had by then delivered a separate batch of Mrs. Clinton’s emails to the committee in August 2014. Those messages were harvested from other state.gov accounts, Mrs. Clinton’s office said.

Dec. 5, 2014: Mrs. Clinton’s office delivers 30,490 printed emails, about 55,000 pages, to the State Department. Mrs. Clinton’s office said 31,830 emails on her account from her tenure as secretary were deemed private and not delivered. To determine which emails should be delivered to the State Department, Mrs. Clinton’s office sorted first by all messages to or from a .gov email address, then searched for names of State Department and other government officials. Mrs. Clinton’s email cache was also searched for messages that included terms like “Benghazi” or “Libya,” her office said.

March 3, 2015: The New York Times reveals that Mrs. Clinton used a private server for her email while she was secretary.

March 4, 2015: Mrs. Clinton writes on Twitter that she asked the State Department to release her messages.

March 10, 2015: Mrs. Clinton speaks publicly about the email matter for the first time, telling reporters she had used a private account because it was more convenient than keeping separate personal and official email addresses.

______________________________________________________

Politics Alerts: Get email alerts on breaking news and big scoops. (NEW!)

Capital Journal Daybreak Newsletter: Sign up to get the latest on politics, policy and defense delivered to your inbox every morning.

----------------

Hillary Clinton said on Twitter late Wednesday that she had asked the State Department to release emails from the personal account she used to conduct official business as secretary of state.

Mrs. Clinton’s statement came amid criticism from Republicans and rising concerns among Democrats over her use of the private account to conduct State Department business.

Here are five things you should know about Mrs. Clinton’s email arrangement:

Some Clinton emails aren’t in State Department custody

Mrs. Clinton’s request for the State Department to release emails apparently refers to 55,000 pages of correspondence from her private account that she turned over to the department late last year, after the department requested such documents from several prior secretaries of state.

Mrs. Clinton’s office has said that all emails relating to official business were included, and that they accounted for 90% of the email messages she sent during her tenure at the State Department.

But it was Mrs. Clinton or her aides who made the determination of which emails to release to the department and which to retain as personal and unrelated to official business. The emails that Mrs. Clinton deemed to be personal presumably would remain private under her request that the department release her records.

The fate of public records requests for Mrs. Clinton’s emails remains unclear

Over the years, many groups and individuals have sought copies of Mrs. Clinton’s emails under federal records-disclosure law. Some groups say their requests produced no records of Mrs. Clinton’s correspondence.

Now, they are wondering whether such records existed but were in the custody of Mrs. Clinton, rather than the State Department.

The liberal environmental group, Friends of the Earth, for example, sought State Department email records as part of its fight against approval of the Keystone XL pipeline. The group was interested in possible communications between Mrs. Clinton and a former campaign aide who became a lobbyist for TransCanada, the company seeking to build the pipeline.

The group filed public-information requests and two lawsuits to obtain emails from the department. It said it eventually received a set of email records that included none from Mrs. Clinton.

Why Mrs. Clinton used a private server remains unclear

Many public employees have employed private email counts instead of or in addition to their government accounts. Less common is the arrangement Mrs. Clinton set up in which she also created a private domain name, clintonemail.com, connected to a computer server linked to her home in Chappaqua, N.Y.

Such an arrangement might give Mrs. Clinton added protections from government or civil subpoenas or record requests, said the Associated Press, which broke news of the server arrangement. Anyone seeking records from her would need to go through her lawyer rather than lawyers for the commercial services that most consumers use, such as Google’s Gmail.

The arrangement may have also carried cybersecurity benefits, as well as risks. But Mrs. Clinton hasn’t explained why she opted for such an arrangement.

Mrs. Clinton isn’t the only public official to use a private domain name and private server

Former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush, who is considering a run for the Republican presidential nomination, also used a personal email account, and he owned his email server, according to spokeswoman Kristy Campbell. She said Mr. Bush had given the state emails related to official business and withheld those related to political work or personal matters, similar to Mrs. Clinton’s policy.

A Bush aide said there were differences between the former governor’s setup and Mrs. Clinton’s: Mr. Bush had the private account before taking office; he turned over the emails contemporaneously; and it was widely known that he used a private email account.

The political fallout of Mrs. Clinton’s email practices remains unclear.

Disclosures about Mrs. Clinton’s email arrangement have drawn much attention in Washington and among party leaders. But it is unclear whether voters care or will judge Mrs. Clinton any differently.

One risk to Mrs. Clinton is that the incident could remind voters of her past, making it harder for her to cast herself as a candidate focused on the future. As first lady, Mrs. Clinton several times drew criticism for excessive secrecy.

In 1993, Mrs. Clinton headed a task force devoted to a health care overhaul and faced criticism for devising a plan behind closed doors, rather than opening meetings to the public.

The following year, federal investigators subpoenaed Mrs. Clinton’s billing records from the Rose Law Firm in Arkansas as part of their investigation into the Whitewater land deal. Two years of searches ensued. Finally, an aide found the missing documents in the White House residence.

Already Republicans are painting Mrs. Clinton’s email system as part of a long-standing effort to cloak her actions. They’ve pointed sardonically to an assertion Mrs. Clinton made in her 2008 presidential campaign: “I think I’m probably the most transparent person in public life.”

MORE: 

Hillary Clinton’s Custom Email Based on Server Near Her Home

Emails Trouble Some Democrats